Sanibel Island, FL Listings Dining Shopping Leisure Highest Rated Dining Paper Fig Kitchen $$ 43 reviews New American, Sandwiches, Salad 2003 Periwinkle WaySanibel, FL 33957 The Sanibel Cafe $$ 259 reviews Breakfast & Brunch, American, Coffee & Tea (239) 472-5323 2007 Periwinkle WaySanibel, FL 33957 Doc Ford's Rum Bar & Grille $$ 1472 reviews Bars, American, Seafood (239) 472-8311 2500 Island Inn RdSanibel, FL 33957 Rosalita’s Cantina $ 52 reviews Breakfast & Brunch, Tex-Mex, Mexican (239) 955-7673 975 Rabbit RdSanibel, FL 33957 The Shipyard $ 14 reviews Bars, Seafood, American (239) 472-5161 15951 Captiva DrCaptiva, FL 33924 Cielo Restaurant $$$ 258 reviews New American, Seafood, Mediterranean (239) 472-5555 1244 Periwinkle WaySanibel, FL 33957 Wickies Lighthouse Restaurant $ 3 reviews Diners, Breakfast & Brunch (239) 472-0011 362 Periwinkle WaySanibel, FL 33957 Mudbugs Cajun Kitchen $$ 509 reviews Cajun/Creole, Seafood, Sandwiches (239) 472-2221 1473 Periwinkle WaySanibel, FL 33957 Phuzzy's Boat Shack $$ 83 reviews Seafood, Sports Bars, American (239) 283-5555 3051 Stringfellow RdSaint James City, FL 33956 Cabbage Key $$ 123 reviews Coffee & Tea, Seafood, Breakfast & Brunch (239) 283-2278 1 Cabbage KyPineland, FL 33922 Old Captiva House $$$ 146 reviews New American, Seafood, Breakfast & Brunch (239) 472-5161 15951 Captiva DrTween Waters Inn T2 Traders $$$ 63 reviews New American, Beer Bar, Wine Bars (239) 558-8919 2340 Periwinkle WaySanibel, FL 33957 Marker 3 Coastal Cantina $ 4 reviews Tex-Mex, Beer Bar, Cocktail Bars (239) 966-4064 3421 Stringfellow RdSaint James City, FL 33956 Kibbe & Company $ 3 reviews Seafood, Seafood Markets (239) 283-1448 2153 Palm AveSaint James City, FL 33956 Waterfront Restaurant & Marina $$ 144 reviews Seafood (239) 283-0592 2131 Oleander StSaint James City, FL 33956 Cafe Italia $ 84 reviews Italian (239) 245-8496 751 Tarpon Bay RdSanibel, FL 33957 Coconuts $$ 71 reviews Bars, American (239) 472-3145 2255 W Gulf DrSanibel, FL 33957 Sweet Melissa's Cafe $$$ 321 reviews New American, Cocktail Bars, Tapas/Small Plates (239) 472-1956 1625 Periwinkle WaySanibel, FL 33957 Traders $$ 361 reviews Seafood, Bars (239) 472-7242 1551 Periwinkle WaySanibel, FL 33957 The Mucky Duck $$ 969 reviews Seafood, American, Desserts (239) 472-3434 11546 Andy Rosse Ln SWCaptiva, FL 33924 Gramma Dot's Restaurant $$ 536 reviews Seafood (239) 472-8138 634 N Yachtsman DrSanibel, FL 33957 Blue Giraffe Restaurant $$ 391 reviews Seafood, American, Breakfast & Brunch (239) 472-2525 2075 Periwinkle WaySte 14 Bleu Rendezvous French Bistro $$$ 96 reviews French, Seafood, Steakhouses (239) 565-1608 751 Tarpon Bay RdSanibel, FL 33957 Crow's Nest Steakhouse $ 13 reviews Steakhouses, Seafood, Cocktail Bars (239) 472-5161 15951 Captiva DrCaptiva, FL 33924 Timbers Restaurant & Fish Market $$ 347 reviews Seafood Markets, Seafood (239) 472-3128 703 Tarpon Bay RdSanibel, FL 33957