Pine Island, FL Listings Dining Shopping Leisure Highest Rated Dining Salty Girls Island Café $$ 207 reviews Seafood, Salad, Breakfast & Brunch (239) 558-4912 10700 Stringsfellow RdSte 20 Tarpon Lodge & Restaurant $$$ 167 reviews American, Resorts (239) 283-3999 13771 Waterfront DrBokeelia, FL 33922 The Eagle’s Nest Restaurant $ 25 reviews Barbeque, Steakhouses, Cocktail Bars (239) 558-5577 10880 Stringfellow RdBokeelia, FL 33922 Blue Dog Bar & Grill $$ 638 reviews Bars, American, Seafood (239) 558-4970 4597 Pine Island Rd NWMatlacha, FL 33993 Pine Island Getaway Cafe $ 62 reviews Cafes, Bakeries (239) 283-3602 5281 Doug Taylor CirSt James City, FL 33956 Waterfront Restaurant & Marina $$ 144 reviews Seafood (239) 283-0592 2131 Oleander StSaint James City, FL 33956 Phuzzy's Boat Shack $$ 83 reviews Seafood, Sports Bars, American (239) 283-5555 3051 Stringfellow RdSaint James City, FL 33956 Micelis Waterfront Restaurant $$ 439 reviews Italian, Pizza (239) 282-8233 3930 Pine Island RdMatlacha, FL 33993 Sun Shrimp $ 4 reviews Food Trucks, Seafood (239) 260-4720 9703 Stringfellow RdSaint James City, FL 33956 Street Eatz & Ale $ 5 reviews Dive Bars, Barbeque, Sandwiches (239) 312-4697 5508 Ave ABokeelia, FL 33922 Old Captiva House $$$ 146 reviews New American, Seafood, Breakfast & Brunch (239) 472-5161 15951 Captiva DrTween Waters Inn Low Key Tiki $$ 62 reviews Seafood, Tiki Bars (239) 282-8454 3135 Stringfellow RdSaint James City, FL 33956 Barnacle's $$ 60 reviews Seafood, Caribbean, New American 4401 Point House TrlCaptiva, FL 33924 Keg & Cow $$ 163 reviews American, Salad, Beer Bar (239) 558-5001 2384 Surfside BlvdCape Coral, FL 33991 Over the Waterfront $$ 39 reviews Seafood (239) 472-4762 4470 Escondido LnCaptiva, FL 33924 Bea's at Pine Island Tropicals Fruit Stand $ 5 reviews Food Stands, Latin American (239) 283-4874 12876 Stringfellow RdBokeelia, FL 33922 Perfect Cup $ 237 reviews Breakfast & Brunch, Coffee Roasteries, Sandwiches (239) 283-4447 4548 Pine Island Rd NWMatlacha, FL 33993 Kibbe & Company $ 3 reviews Seafood, Seafood Markets (239) 283-1448 2153 Palm AveSaint James City, FL 33956 Yucatan Waterfront Bar & Grill $$ 270 reviews American, Seafood, Breakfast & Brunch (239) 283-0113 4875 Pine Island RdMatlacha, FL 33993 That BBQ Place $ 39 reviews Barbeque, Smokehouse (239) 312-8557 4590 Pine Island Rd NWMatlacha, FL 33993 Marker 3 Coastal Cantina $ 4 reviews Tex-Mex, Beer Bar, Cocktail Bars (239) 966-4064 3421 Stringfellow RdSaint James City, FL 33956 Harborside Bar & Grill $$ 53 reviews Seafood, Bars, Breakfast & Brunch (866) 565-5089 5400 S Seas Plantation RdSouth Seas Island Resort La Vang Tropical Fruit Farm & Garden/Vuon Trái Cây La Vang $ 31 reviews Fruits & Veggies, Vietnamese (239) 222-3323 9203 Stringfellow RdSt James City, FL 33956 Mainstay $ 8 reviews American 4401 Point House TrlCaptiva, FL 33924 Pine Island Pizza $ 40 reviews Pizza, Salad, Chicken Wings (239) 283-7992 5465 Pine Island RdSte 2&3